Supergirl Review: Milly Alcock is good even if the movie isn’t

In a universe where destiny is forged in the fires of vengeance, a young girl named Eve Ridley finds herself thrust into a desperate battle against cosmic evil. Her quest takes an unexpected turn when she recruits Supergirl to help her seek justice for her family’s tragic demise at the hands of a ruthless space pirate named Krem.

The stakes are immediate and intense: a race against time to find an antidote after the villain poisons someone close to her. This framework sets up an urgent adventure, but as the narrative unfolds, it grapples with the broader challenges facing modern superhero cinema.

While the story provides high-octane action, critics note that Supergirl feels like a film existing in the shadow of countless others. It navigates familiar cinematic territory, often leaning heavily on techniques—like speed-ramping and slow motion—that feel dated rather than exciting. The visual style draws heavy inspiration from films like Mad Max: Fury Road, which contributes to an overall feeling of derivative action that lacks a truly fresh signature.

The villain Krem, though undeniably evil in his actions—trafficking, mistreatment, and violence—is largely presented as a simplified iteration of established cinematic antagonists. This narrative simplicity, coupled with the genre’s reliance on familiar story beats, makes the conflict feel less original than filmmakers hoped for.

Despite the structural critiques, the film possesses moments that shine brightly. Milly Alcock delivers a compelling performance as Supergirl, portraying a character who carries deep trauma and undergoes genuine emotional evolution throughout the narrative. She successfully embodies an antiheroine, evolving from guardedness to conviction, proving she has the depth needed for the role.

Further bolstering the film is the supporting cast. Jason Momoa’s limited but energetic appearance as Lobo injects much-needed swagger and dynamism into the action sequences. While the overall package might feel like an assembly-line blockbuster—a product of a franchise focused heavily on adaptation rather than innovation—it succeeds in delivering compelling performances.

Ultimately, Supergirl is not a cinematic failure, but it remains a reflection of the broader genre’s struggle. It demonstrates that while strong performances can carry an effort, making something truly distinctive in a crowded space requires more than just rearranging familiar action sequences. It stands as a solid, if somewhat generic, launch for a character who deserves a more unique and memorable story.

Buy on Amazon