The story behind cinematic choices often involves more than just box office numbers; sometimes it delves into the complex world of comic book lore and creative interpretation. In the case of the upcoming Supergirl film, a high-profile screenwriter admitted that her vision for the narrative diverged significantly from the source material, prompting an interesting discussion about adaptation and character motivation.
Supergirl writer Ana Nogueira revealed that she misinterpreted Tom King’s comic book ending. She had envisioned a far darker resolution where Ruthye, driven by lingering anger, ultimately killed Krem, leading to what she described as a “quite dark ending” where the villain essentially changes, and Ruthye takes ultimate action.
However, King offered a different perspective on the narrative’s conclusion. He clarified that in the comics, Krem survives; Ruthye does not forgive him but still harbors intense hatred. The comic’s resolution involves Ruthye hitting Krem with her cane before walking away, solidifying an unresolved emotional conflict rather than a final act of violence.
This difference in interpretation led to a major creative pivot for the film. Instead of adapting the tragic fate Nogueira had envisioned, the filmmakers chose a path that emphasized Kara’s moral development and agency. In the movie, Kara is instrumental in ensuring Krem’s survival, stabbing him only after convincing Ruthye not to commit murder.
Nogueira explained that this shift was deliberate: they wanted Kara to possess a unique moral compass that operated independently of Superman’s established ethics. By having Kara bring about justice without burdening the child with lethal vengeance, the narrative aimed to explore new possibilities for character growth within the DC Universe.
This artistic decision mirrors the direction taken by the film’s director, Craig Gillespie, who had previously insisted that James Gunn remain adamant about filming the original scripted ending. The creative team made a conscious choice to give Kara a moral framework distinct from her larger-than-life counterpart, setting the stage for exciting and complex future stories in the franchise.
Buy on Amazon
Credit: ComingSoon.net
