Other Mommy: Blumhouse hit but audiences slam it D+
The weekend box office is a fascinating, often contradictory place—a landscape where critical acclaim rarely aligns with opening weekend performance, and global success often trumps domestic disappointment. This past weekend provided a perfect illustration of that tension, pitting high-concept cinema against established franchises, and prestige dramas against animated features.
Leading the charge was Blumhouse’s Other Mommy, starring Jessica Chastain. Despite universally poor reviews, the film pulled in a strong $27.5 million domestically, exceeding earlier predictions. What made it even more interesting was its global performance, netting $17.7 million overseas, pushing the worldwide total to a solid $45.2 million. Yet, the film’s rarity in the industry was its CinemaScore: a rare D+, suggesting that while audiences enjoyed the spectacle, the cinematic experience itself was deeply divisive.
The real story, however, is in the dramatic divergence. While some films struggle domestically, others demonstrate remarkable international appeal. For instance, Verity managed to carve out a strong presence, pulling in $53.8 million domestically and an impressive $113.9 million overseas. Meanwhile, the perennial giant Resident Evil continued its relentless march, bringing in $8.35 million this weekend domestically. Its international performance was staggering, generating $54.3 million overseas and a global total of $320 million, raising the tantalizing possibility of a multi-hundred-million dollar finish.
Another story of international strength was Heart of the Beast, which performed considerably better abroad, bringing in $131 million globally despite a more modest domestic total just shy of $50 million. This contrast highlights how success is measured differently across borders.
On the other side of the coin, some ambitious projects faced tougher odds. Aaron Sorkin’s prestige offering, The Social Reckoning, opened with a disappointing $5.5 million, though its $30 million budget provides a buffer. Similarly, DreamWorks’ animated Forgotten Island posted $4.5 million this weekend domestically but struggled overseas, resulting in a global total of only $50.2 million.
Amidst these shifts, the chase for massive spectacle continued. Tom Cruise’s Digger saw a weekend gross of $3.2 million, but its global tally remained modest at $35.3 million. It remains an outlier for Cruise, marking what many consider the lowest point in his box office career. Even Western remakes, like Angel Studios’ Angel and the Badman, saw limited theatrical release, suggesting a shift toward streaming for these types of productions.
However, the cinematic landscape found a powerful moment of resurgence with Christopher Nolan’s The Odyssey. By leveraging the release of other major films, including the surrender of IMAX screens by WB for Digger, The Odyssey made a massive comeback. It earned $2 million this weekend, representing a 54% increase from the previous week, and continues to dominate the global market with a domestic total of $622 million and an overseas total of $1.779 billion.
As we look toward the next weekend, the slate is packed with high-stakes action and intriguing arthouse features. Street Fighter and Whalefall are poised to make a splash, while A24 is eyeing an intriguing arthouse hit with its meta You Can See Everything. The box office remains a thrilling, unpredictable arena, constantly reminding us that global success often demands a wider lens than domestic applause.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
