The Great Dictator Review: Chaplin Takes On Hitler
9/10 — The Great Dictator (1940)
Pros
- Chaplin's dual performance
- Brilliant globe scene
- Powerful closing speech
Cons
- Abrupt tonal shifts
A Jewish barber, who looks identical to the dictator of Tomainia, is mistaken for him, with comic and dramatic results. Chaplin plays both roles, in a satire released before the US entered the Second World War.
What works
The balletic globe scene is a perfect piece of comedy, and Chaplin’s gibberish speeches are hilarious. The final speech is passionate and moving, a bold statement in 1940.
Where it falters
The tonal swings between slapstick and sincerity are abrupt, and the final speech is sometimes criticised as preachy.
Verdict
Brave, funny and moving. A great comedy with a message.
