Ryan Murphy addresses the backlash over bad reviews
The journey of television creator Ryan Murphy has been a masterclass in navigating the often-turbulent waters of critical reception. While some of his acclaimed work has garnered universal praise, the landscape of his output has frequently been marked by controversy and harsh commentary.
From some of his earlier creations, like Pose and Feud, Murphy managed to establish a foundation of respect. However, as his television catalog expanded, critics often found themselves divided, leveling sharp critiques against titles such as Scream Queens, American Horror Story, The Shards, and even Ratched.
Even his most popular dramas, including the legal saga Monster and the legal procedural All’s Fair, faced negative reviews despite their undeniable popularity and successful renewals. This tension between mass appeal and critical approval often defines the trajectory of highly successful creative works.
When asked about the critical response to his career, Murphy offered a refreshing perspective. He suggested that the critics often missed the mark entirely, noting that much of his work was made for an audience that appreciated a specific kind of heightened, ’80s soapy procedural style.
“I think the critics are wrong,” Murphy shared. “If you look at my career since I started, almost everything that I have made was never embraced critically. I made it for people who loved that heightened ’80s soapy procedural thing. The critics called it camp, but camp is a lack of awareness. My work has awareness.”
He pointed out that while he used to be swayed by outside opinions, he learned the importance of self-belief. He recalled that a piece of mentor advice helped him navigate the noise: “You know what? Just because they put a chalice of delicious poison in front of you doesn’t mean you have to drink it.”
This approach suggests a shift from seeking external validation to trusting the vision. Ultimately, Murphy’s work continues to captivate audiences, proving that sometimes, popularity triumphs over predictable criticism.
All’s Fair is gearing up for a second run, set to return in November, continuing its journey with viewers.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
