SNL’s Legacy in the Competition It Inspired
The cultural footprint of Saturday Night Live is undeniable. With over five decades of history and a cast that spans generations, it remains a monumental force in American television. Yet, beneath the spotlight of this behemoth lies a fascinating, often overlooked history: the ripple effect of the shows it inspired, particularly the smaller, scrappier entities that competed for comedic hearts.
When we look back at the history of sketch comedy, the story of Second City Television (SCTV) offers a compelling counterpoint. Launched just a year after SNL, SCTV operated on a completely different wavelength. While SNL was a high-wire spectacle—a weekly event defined by celebrity hosts, New York settings, and musical guests—SCTV was a more intimate, focused experience. Taped from Toronto, it was driven purely by comedy, exploring interconnected sketches that lampooned pop culture conventions with a delightful, subtle wit.
This difference in scale led to a fascinating dynamic. Although SCTV was created to provide an outlet for Toronto’s comedy talent, SNL often viewed it as a potential talent pool. There is a notable story about the initial friction between the two institutions—a moment where creators from the larger show sought out talent from the smaller one. A botched audition involving creators from SNL and SCTV stars reportedly resulted in a profound rejection, illustrating the subtle hierarchies that existed in the world of television.
As time progressed, the influences began to cross. When creators returned to the helm of SNL, they brought new sensibilities. The development of The Kids in the Hall series, created by Lorne Michaels, showcased a far more daring, dark, and cinematic approach than traditional sketch work. Though not a ratings blockbuster, this series fostered a deep devotion among its audience, proving that sometimes, the most impactful comedy doesn’t require massive numbers.
The decade of the 1990s was a competitive crucible for sketch comedy. While SNL faced internal controversy and external pressures, it also navigated a burgeoning landscape of competition. Shows like The Ben Stiller Show shared a stylistic DNA with SCTV, while even more subversive gems like The State demonstrated a knack for targeting the younger demographic with a sharper edge. Meanwhile, In Living Color exploded onto the scene, offering broader opportunities and, perhaps more importantly, providing a platform for diverse voices and comedic talent.
But the true evolution of comedy often happens outside the main pipeline. The rise of internet-driven content has empowered niche voices, creating a space for comedy that doesn’t rely on mainstream acceptance. Shows like Chappelle’s Show and newer, highly viral properties like I Think You Should Leave have found a massive audience by prioritizing specific comedic awkwardness and relatable absurdity. These newer successes demonstrate that a profound cultural impact can be achieved by tapping into a niche, uninhibited voice, proving that the legacy of SNL extends far beyond the traditional sketch format.
Ultimately, the ongoing story of television comedy is one of constant reaction and rebellion. While SNL remains a towering institution, its legacy is enhanced by the alternative voices it spurred, proving that the greatest impact lies not just in the spectacle, but in the vibrant, chaotic ecosystem of comedy that surrounds it.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
