The Paper runs out of ink in Season 2
When a show borrows the DNA of a cultural phenomenon, the expectations are sky-high. This is the case with the Peacock comedy series The Paper. Co-created by Greg Daniels, the visionary behind The Office, the series transports viewers into a familiar, yet uniquely chaotic, workplace environment. It features the same dysfunctional dynamics and office shenanigans, complete with Oscar Nuñez reprising his role as Oscar Martinez.
Despite the promising start of its first season, the question remains: can this spin-off match the enduring brilliance of its predecessor? While the show offers moments of sharp writing and a genuinely appealing cast, the overall experience is breezy but uneven. It’s clever, certainly, but it sometimes leans into the contrived, leaving the audience wondering if it has the staying power required to become a long-running classic.
The narrative centers on the struggles of the Toledo Truth Teller, a newspaper teetering on the edge. The staff is constantly battling for resources, struggling to staff the newsroom with inexperienced journalists, all while trying to maintain the integrity of their work. The pressure cooker environment provides fertile ground for the kind of absurdity that defines workplace comedy.
Beyond the office politics, the series offers a tender subplot: the nascent romance between editor-in-chief Ned Sampson and reporter Mare Pritti. Their developing connection offers a dose of classic workplace romance, sparking an endearing tension that audiences root for as they navigate their professional and personal lives.
The show truly shines when it embraces the darker side of human nature. The best moments emerge when the staff pools their resources for bizarre tasks, whether it’s putting together an obituary for a truly terrible person or when the Human Resources department, led by the hilarious Lisa Gilroy, asks spectacularly inappropriate questions to their colleagues. These moments inject a necessary layer of witty, politically incorrect humor into the fabric of the series.
The supporting cast is equally memorable, with characters like Melvin Gregg’s Detrick Moore, Gbemisola Ikumelo’s Adelola Olofin, and Tim Key’s Ken Davies delivering elevated performances. When these characters pursue stories in unconventional ways, the ensemble dynamic becomes truly captivating.
However, not every element of the comedy lands with the same precision. While the series enjoys the “anything goes” spirit of sketch comedy, some of the characters’ behavior occasionally veers into the genuinely bizarre and unsettling. This is where the balance must be carefully managed; the tone needs to remain funny, not alarming. The sharp comedic precision found in shows like Seinfeld or Arrested Development is missing.
Some performers, while talented, occasionally overshadow the narrative. For instance, while Sabrina Impacciatore delivered a sensational performance in other roles, her portrayal of Valentina in the series felt more cartoonishly broad than funny. Similarly, some characters’ antics flirt with the unhinged, prompting viewers to wonder if the show needs a therapy session before each episode.
Ultimately, The Paper is a good paper. It is a pleasant, sometimes clever, and often darkly humorous look at the pressures of journalism and working life. It deserves to stay in circulation, offering a unique perspective on the often absurd realities of the newsroom.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
